The Day the Death Penalty Died (Temporarily)

Protesters holding signs opposing the death penalty outside the U.S. Supreme Court.

What Happened?

By the early 1970s, America’s death penalty system was a mess. It was inconsistent, racially biased, and lacked any clear standards. Who lived and who died often came down to the color of your skin, your zip code, or the mood of the jury that day.

In Furman v. Georgia, the Supreme Court consolidated three death row cases and took a long, hard look at how states were handing out death sentences. The result? A 5–4 ruling that declared the current system unconstitutional under the Eighth Amendment’s ban on 'cruel and unusual punishment.'

Justice Potter Stewart wrote that death sentences were being imposed 'so wantonly and so freakishly' that they resembled being 'struck by lightning.'

The decision didn’t outlaw the death penalty itself—it just forced every state to hit pause and rethink the whole system. As a result, over 600 people had their death sentences commuted overnight. Executions stopped nationwide.

But the ruling sparked backlash. States rushed to rewrite their capital punishment laws to make them appear more 'fair' and less arbitrary—standardizing procedures, creating bifurcated trials, and introducing aggravating factors.

By 1976, the Court reversed course in Gregg v. Georgia, allowing executions to resume under the new frameworks. The machinery of death creaked back to life—but Furman left a permanent scar on the system’s reputation.

Since then, more than 190 people sentenced to death have been exonerated. The legacy of Furman lives on in every argument against capital punishment, every statistic that shows its racial bias, and every wrongful conviction overturned too late.

Why It Matters

The Furman decision cracked the illusion of justice wide open. It revealed a system so broken that even the highest court in the land had to call it out. It didn’t end the death penalty, but it exposed the truth behind it: a punishment that says more about the people with power than the people it targets.

?

Dig Deeper

How the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Furman v. Georgia exposed the racial bias and randomness of capital punishment.

Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society was one of the most ambitious domestic reform agendas in U.S. history.

The Great Society: Government as a Force for Good

The Great Society wasn’t just a policy agenda, it was a radical vision of what America could be. With sweeping reforms in health care, education, civil rights, immigration, and the environment, President Johnson’s plan aimed to eliminate poverty and racial injustice once and for all.

Wilmington, 1898, a white supremacist mob burned the Black-owned newspaper, massacred dozens of Black residents, forced out the elected government, and installed their own mayor at gunpoint. It was the only successful coup d’état in U.S. history.

The Wilmington Coup: When Democracy Was Burned Down

In 1898, Wilmington, North Carolina had a thriving Black middle class, a multiracial government — and then a white mob overthrew it. Armed. Organized. Violent. This was no riot. It was a coup.

Throughout history, protest has been a force that drives change—from the civil rights movement to climate activism.

The Right to Protest & Civil Disobedience: How Activism Shapes Democracy

From labor strikes to mass demonstrations, activism has been the engine of social change. But what makes a movement successful? This deep dive explores the different roles in activism, the power of civil disobedience, and why protests are essential to democracy.